The first read through of William's “Spring and All” was a rollercoaster, to say the least. There were times where I felt strongly in agreement with what he was saying, but just as quickly as I said “yes!” he would drop to a single line or string of thoughts that left me instead asking “what?” However, the second time reading it through and with the incorporated class discussions I became much fonder of the piece and all its complexities.
I think William's strongest feature, in a general sense, is his energy. It is not only the energy that he applies to his work, but also the life that he gives to it. This is interesting for he emphasizes the fact that imagination gives words and phrases life, while he himself is giving his words life. On page 224 he writes “The fixed categories into which life is divided must always hold. These things are normal-- essential to every activity. But they exist-- but not as dead dissections.” I think what he means here is that these every day “things” or words appear disconnected and meaningless until imagination allows them to go beyond their every day connotation and evolve into something else; adapt meaning. Two paragraphs following the above quote, he concludes this though by stating “The same things exist, but in different condition when energized by the imagination” (224).
Another point that I found really interesting and could relate personally to is his idea that life exists whether we realize it or not. It is almost a floating complex of beings, figures, and sensations, but it is only considered “life” when one relates it personally to oneself and creates meaning in the term. Williams phrases it a bit better when stating “life becomes actual only when it is identified with ourselves. When we name it, life exists” (202). I believe this holds true to numerous aspects of life. Things can exist freely with no real attachment to a person, but once that person recognizes it and identifies with it either by naming it or just expending some form of energy on it, it becomes real. This idea of creating actuality out of already existing forms returns to William's notion of imagination and its truly unique abilities. So much of imagination's job is to observe and embrace what already is, but the [arguably] more important job is expanding that..distorting and manipulating it so that it can become something fantastic. It stimulates senses and creativity about objects or experiences, not just record it.
In the question of Modernism and Williams take on the term, I agree that he fits into both definitions. He definitely makes his voice heard and reaches out to the world, writing of Shakespeare and evoking many senses through his poetry. However I believe that Modernism for Williams is more about the construction of meaning. It is all he seems to write about. Words are just words and facts are just facts until imagination gives them meaning. Imagination is the true vehicle of creating and demonstrating value in otherwise dull and lifeless words. I've never thought so much about imagination. The term has always held a somewhat fantastical and colorful connotation in my mind, but not one that I would think of existing in everything around me. Williams has definitely got the wheels going in my head, and I like it.
Emily, I feel exactly the same way about how this piece seemed like a rollercoaster at first but once we discussed it in class and read it over again it became very accessible, interesting and relevant. I think you’ve captured the essence of Williams and his ideas in this piece very accurately. Imagination is a key point throughout this work and you’ve summarized the main points very well. I really liked how you summarized Williams’ take on life: “It is almost a floating complex of beings, figures, and sensations, but it is only considered ‘life’ when one relates it personally to oneself and creates meaning in the term.” And again, I agree with your interpretation about imagination giving words and facts meaning: “Words are just words and facts are just facts until imagination gives them meaning. Imagination is the true vehicle of creating and demonstrating value in otherwise dull and lifeless words.”
ReplyDeleteAs far as the binaries go, I think you’ve got it right when you say that Williams fits into both binaries but that he leans more towards “the construction of meaning”. Williams definitely focused on the words he used and what they mean, especially once imagination is applied to them.
Williams was difficult to understand but I think you did an amazing job of pulling out the key points and discussing them well.
I agree--I think this is a good analysis of Williams' tone and intentions for "Spring and All." I particularly enjoyed the point about Williams' energy and his attitude toward language. He talks extensively about the life given to objects by the imagination; I agree with your point about how even language is merely words until it is perceived and given meaning. Williams draws attention to this throughout the work with his energetic and at times playful use of language. this become more evident as the text goes on and Williams frequently will stop a line or idea and jump to something else entirely. From this we are both left to decide how to finish his thought and are also aware of our ability to bring meaning to his piece. A favorite line of mine to this effect is when he announces, "There is no end--" jumping to an entirely new paragraph and carrying on with the text. Along with a touch of irony, this particular line indeed makes sense; there is no end, because we, the reader, can imagine what ideas/words can fill those voids, by means of the imagination.
ReplyDeleteI agree 100% with the text being a roller coaster ride in the beginning. My mind going from completely agreeing or at least understanding to not understanding or following at all. I have never really read poetry so the understanding process of it was very out of my mind. I came to class thinking I was the only one who had no idea what was going on in the text. As class discussions arose I found it a little easier to understand exactly what was being told in a poem. Poems I realized very quickly go much further then its words, or its word placement or even its over all picture or feel the reader gets. There are questions to ask yourself when reading and thats what took my by such great surprise. I had always just thought that in a poem you read it and understand it. I think Emily hits Williams right on the dot when saying his poems represent energy. Its the vibe I had gotten from the beginning. The Imagination can take someone so much further then words, it can take you to a place, a feeling, a taste, a different world, Williams leaves everything open for as much imagination as one can let oneself. Life: I think Emily had an amazing point with this- so does so wonderfully make you feel, along with realize "life" exists whether we realize it or not. Its everywhere around you and in you. As Emily said "either by naming it or just expanding some form of energy to it, it becomes real."
ReplyDelete